Monday, July 31, 2023
Indian Regiments marching in Paris Bastille Day Parade, 14 July 2023
(Notice: I have not written a post in almost three months, but am making up with this post...) Time has gone by very quickly since my last post in early May on my trip to the North Georgia Mountains. When I returned to my house in Cobb County, GA., the water heater needed to be replaced. Then in June I traveled to Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, to spend time with my daughter Celine and her family. I had planned to write a post on this visit but had to return to my house in Georgia in early July because two trees had fallen on the roof.
As I am writing this post my air conditioning unit stopped working on Friday in the upper part of the house in Nashville. My bedroom temperature went up to 97 F (36 C,) making it difficult to have a good night sleep. The Weather Forecast Channel on TV just told us to expect more warm days coming up - feeling like 117 F (47.2C) in Nashville. Scientists are saying that this month of July 2023 has been the warmest on record so far and might even be the warmest the planet has experienced in 120,000 years! But, no fear, my hairdresser in Georgia told me last week that there is no climate change, it's just a "liberal" plot ... (Cartoon courtesy New Orleans The Times Picayune.)
Through the plantation shutters next to my laptop desk I can see little birds getting a relief from the heat in the small water dish I placed on the front porch. It is the bottom dish of a large planter. I also placed a "Mosquito Dunk" tablet in it to avoid mosquito larvae (non toxic to birds, pets, animals or humans) that I purchased on Amazon. I like watching all the different birds having a good time, sometimes up to 6 or 8 of them at a time.
In spite of my house problems I was able to watch the Paris 14 of July celebrations on the French Military Armed Forces website and also on the Mayor of Paris website. The French National Holiday is called "Le 14 Juillet" (14 July) but English speaking people call it "Bastille Day" after the storming of the Bastille prison in 1789 during the French Revolution (however, in France, no one would know what you mean if you asked about Bastille Day.) What people don't realize here is that there were only 3 prisoners in the huge Bastille jail then. The people had stormed it because it contained arms and ammunitions, not to free the 3 prisoners. In previous posts I explained the history of the holiday; please look under Bastille Day on the right side of my blog.
The celebrations start on the evening of July 13 with a torchlight procession, that is, participants in many cities and villages walk down streets holding torches or lanterns/lampoons in their hands, following a local band, then go on to a public square for public dancing. On the morning of the 14 there is the traditional Défilé Militaire du 14 juillet, or Bastille Day Military Parade, down the Champs-Elysees. Started in 1880, it is one of the oldest military parades in the world. It is the main official event honoring French military regiments and includes each year different invited foreign guests and regiments. This is one of the main occasions when you will see many French flags all around. French people respect their flag but the rest of the time they don't have it on their cars, or flown from their houses, etc. You will see it in official places like schools, police stations, customs check-points, and in support of the national teams during international competitions but you won't find it in front of a commercial business, or on tee-shirts, baseball caps, clothes or other decorative objects. As in many European countries (apart from the UK that is a constitutional monarchy)people placing out too many national flags are frown upon and considered to be extreme-right extremists, or uber nationalists. In addition, there is no "Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag" in France like in the United States. Again, most European citizens of democratic countries would find it quite bizarre, not saying undemocratic, incredibly creepy and borderline fascistic.
For 2023, the Bastille Day parade included 6,500 people (5,100 of them marching,) 64 planes, 28 helicopters, 157 ground vehicles, 62 motorcycles, 200 horses and 86 dogs. Nearly 15 countries were invited to the parade including India, this year guest of honor. Prime Minister Norendra Modi watched the parade alongside French President Emmanuel Macron. It was also the 25th anniversary of the India-France Strategic Partnership and the 70th anniversary of the Patrouille de France. The Patrouille had their traditional aerial display that included French-made Indian war planes. Vehicles on display included the Caesar anti-missile batteries that France is providing to Ukraine, and Ukrainian officials were also invited to join Pres. Macron in the VIP seats. Below Patrouille de France (courtesy Ministeres des Armees.)
Another highlight were students from partner African military schools (Benin, Congo-Brazzavile, Gabon, Madagascar, Ivory Coast and Senegal) marching with residents of French military schools. Below photos of two of the African military schools in the parade, from Madagascar on top photo and Ivory Coast on the bottom. (Courtesy Madagascar Tribune.)
In tribute to the 80th anniversary of the disappearance of Jean Moulin, the French civil servant hero who created the National Council of the French Resistance, musicians played the "Chant des partisants," a song that is a symbol of indomitable spirit against evil. This was the French Resistance anthem during World War II. Jean Moulin, 1899-1943, the leader of the Resistance, was tortured by the Nazis in one prison after another and died in 1943 in a train taking him to Germany. An international orchestra, made up of 80 musicians from France and 14 partner countries (Canada, The Czech Republic, Belgium, Germany, Hungary, Italy, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Spain, the United Kingdom and the United States) played for the parade until the Patrouille de France flew over.
The parade included a 269 member tri-services contingent of the Indian Armed Forces with 77 marching personnel and 38 band members (including the Rajputana Rifles Regiment Band,) led by Captain Aman Jagtap. The Indian Navy contingent was being led by Commander Vrat Baghel, while Squadron Leader Sindhu Reddy lead the Indian Air Force contingent. The Punjab Regiment had been selected to represent the Indian Army for this Bastille Day celebrations. The Punjab Regiment, one of the oldest Infantry Regiments of the Indian Army that traces its origins to 1761, had participated in both World Wars as well as post-independence operations. Historically, 107 years ago, the Punjab Regiment had marched down the Champs-Elysees for the 14 July 1916 parade, after taking part in some battles of World War I. (Photos courtesy Ministere des Armees, La Ville de Paris, and the Élysée Palace.) Please click on collage to enlarge.
Below are vintage photographs and postcards of the Punjab Regiment at the 14 July parade of 1916 and at the rail station Gare du Nord (below right.) Top left photo is a French lady pinning a flower in gratitude on one of the Indian soldiers' lapel.
World War I began on August 4, 1914, after Great Britain declared war against Germany. When the British Army requested military support from their Indian colony, Sikhs, Pendjabis and Gurkas arrived in Marseille, France. On September 26, 1914, the British Punjab's 20th troop of the Lahore Division and of the 129th Baluchis of pre-partition India were the first colonial force to deploy in Europe. They trained in Marseille while waiting to be sent to the front lines. Below are vintage postcards of the Anglo-Indian regiments in Marseille, France in Sept. 1914.
Then these Anglo-Indian troops went to Toulouse and Orleans, France, on their way north. Between September 1914 and October 1918, 140,000 Indian troops arrived to fight in France and Belgium. Below are vintage postcards of them in France.
As you can see there were quite a few Indian troops in the First World War, but I have never heard about them in the US - they must have been forgotten here. I tried to find books in English on this subject, but could not, but I did find books published in France. Below a couple of them plus an article on the Excelsior Journal published in France on December 14, 1914, showing injured Indian soldiers.
In the north of France they took part in an offensive near Neuve-Chapelle from March 10 to 13, 1915, earning the Battle Honors "Loos" and "France and Flanders" - over 8,550 were killed and as many as 50,000 more were wounded. In total about 10,000 Indian soldiers died in France during the First World War. Several monuments in their honor were erected in France, notably the Neuve-Chapelle Memorial. It was inaugurated on 7 October, 1927, by Marshal Foch, and attended by the Maharaja of Karputhala, Rudyard Kipling and a large contingent of Indian veterans representing units that fought in France, including Sikhs, Dogras and Garhwalis. Marshal Ferdinand Foch (French, 1851-1919,) the Supreme Commander of the Allied Forces (and generally considered the leader most reponsible for the Allied victory,) gave a speech, including this: "Return to your homes in the distant, sun-bathed East and proclaim how your countrymen drenched with their blood the cold northern land of France and Flanders, and how they delivered it by their ardent spirit from the firm grip of a determined army; tell all India that we shall watch over their graves with the devotion due to all our dead. We shall cherish above all the memory of their example. They showed us the way, they made the first steps towards the final victory." Speaking after the war, Marshal Foch said the Indian Army had delivered the war's first decisive steps to victory; they were critical in stemming the tide of the German invasion of Belgium and France. Without their early arrival, the port of Calais would not have been saved, the Western Front would have been breached and the British Expeditionary Forces annihilated. Below photos of the Neuve-Chapelle Indian Memorial.
Again in World War II, 1.5 million Anglo-Indian soldiers (including Muslims, Hindus and Sikhs) came to defend Africa and Europe. 130,000 of them came to France where thousands died or were wounded. They earned 16 Battle Honors and 14 Theatre Honors. On May 28, 1940, 300 Indian soldiers (all of them Muslims) and 23 British troops evacuated the city of Dunkirk, but their story has been mostly forgotten, as well as in movies about Dunkirk. Read about it here or on the BBC report here. (World War Two: The forgotten Indian soldiers of Dunkirk.) Numerous soldiers hailing from former French trading posts in India - now in present day Pondicherry/Puducherry - also fought in France. France never forgot the suffering and heroism of all these men. President Macron tweeted "This 14 July, soldiers and Rafale aircraft from India are marching and flying alongside our troops. We honor the memory of those who fough with the French in the two World Wars." Photo below British Indian Army Service Corps on parade in France in 1940 (courtesy Wikipedia.)
Another unsung hero coming from India was Noor Inayat Khan (1914-1944) the descendant of Indian royalty. She was the daughter of an Indian Sufi mystic, Inayat Khan, born in Bombay. He lived in Europe as a musician and teacher of Sufism where he became the head of the "Sufi Order of the West." Her mother was an American, Ora Ray Baker, born in Albuquerque, New Mexico. Noor, also known as Nora Baker, was an SOE agent under the French Resistance, her code name was "Madeleine." She was the first female wireless operator sent from the UK to aid the French Resistance during World War II. She was betrayed, captured, tortured then executed at the Dachau concentration camp in Germany. On January 16, 1946, French President Charles de Gaulle awarded her the Croix de Guerre (highest civilian honor.) She was also honored with the British S. George Cross. There is a plaque (shown below) outside her family home in Suresnes, France. A band plays there every year on Bastille Day. A square in the city of Suresnes has been named Cours Madeleine after her. Photos courtesy the National Archives and Noor Inayat Khan Memorial Trust: top left Noor and her mother Ora, next to Noor playing her veena instrument; bottom photo of Noor's family.
A school in Suresnes, a city 9.3 km (5.7 miles) from the center of Paris, is named after her.
French history with India is a long one, over three centuries, from 1674 to 1954. I remember when I was a small girl studying in Paris public primary school, France still had trading posts in India. I had to memorize their difficult to pronounce names. They sounded so exotic - I dreamed of visiting these far-away places. I have not yet, but it's still on my list... In 1673, under the reign of French King Louis XIV, France purchased Chandernagore from the Mughal Governor of Bengal. The following year France purchased Pondicherry from the Sultan of Bijapur, and other parts of south India. After the Treaty of Paris of 1763 France only kept five "comptoirs" (or trading posts) in India: Pondicherry, Chandernagor, Karikal, Mahe and Yanaon. (I still remember their names!) When India obtained its independence from the UK in 1947, talks were taken to return four of the French comptoirs to the Indian Union. This was done on November 1, 1954. However the people of Pondicherry were pro-French and feared the overpowering weight of the Indian administrative machinery. After several years of negotiations, an agreement was reached between France and India and a treaty was ratified by the French Parliament in July 1962. By this treaty Pondicherry became Indian Territory and its inhabitants Indian nationals. However, France gave them a six-month opportunity to obtain French citizenship - 8000 of them signed up. It was difficult for them to decide as they were Indians but also went to French schools, spoke French and had been imbued with French culture.
Of course, now sixty-two years later, the French influence in Pondicherry is fading away, but still...it retains some French culture, for example the headgear of the policemen represents the design adopted in France. There are many French-style houses left along the Bay of Bengal. Pondicherry has a large "French" area in town, with French city streets, cobblestones, restaurants, etc. French is one of the official languages of the Pondicherry's government. A French church, built in 1855, offers mass in three languages - Tamil, French and English. Many streets have retained their French names. There are still 5,500 French-Indian and French people living there, many retire there from France as well. A few years ago the film "The Life of Pi" was filmed in Pondicherry, starting with a scene in the shaded and peaceful Jardins Botaniques. (Photos courtesy Pondy Tourism.)
Pondicherry, Pondichéry in French, Pondy for short or Puducherry, as it is officially known, is not a large town. It is about 150 miles from the large city of Chennai (was Madras) on the south eastern coast of India. It's a little bit of France in India. The French Quarter is reminiscent of the New Orleans French Quarter. There is a French Consulate (see their sign in the heading photo) French school and college, The Alliance Francaise, French bakeries and shops and, of course, the celebrations of the 14 of July, or Bastille Day in India.
Bastille Day is a yearly festival in Pondy. On the evening of the 13th there is a lantern march along the Beach Promenade followed by a public dancing for 600 people. Several buildings are illuminated in blue, white and red after the French flag. The police band plays national songs of India and France as part of the celebration. On the 14th, there is a march to the monuments honoring French-Indians and Indians who died in the wars and also to the statue of Mahatma Gandhi (that is illuminated in the tri-colors.) In the evening of the 14th traditional fireworks are fired in front of the French Consulate. I don't think another foreign country in Asia (or anywhere else) sponsors an official French Bastille Day.
Meanwhile, in Paris, on this July 14, 2023, the crowd attended the usual free concert followed by the fireworks shot from the Eiffel Tower. (Photos courtesy City of Paris.)
21 comments:
I enjoy reading comments from visitors to my blog. Please leave a comment below. If you do not have an account you can post in Anonymous but leave a first name. Thank you.
J'aime lire les commentaires des visiteurs de mon blog. S'il vous plaît laissez un commentaire ci-dessous. Si vous n'avez pas un compte vous pouvez poster dans Anonymous mais veuillez laisser un prénom. Merci.
Because of much spam, comments are monitored before being published.
I found 20 excellent books about Indian action in the 1914-18 war. Start with Army of Empire by George Morton-Jack and Indian Soldiers in WW1 by Andrew Jarboe.
ReplyDeleteHels
Art & Architecture, mainly
It is lovely to see another post from you. I was a little worried about your long absence. Thank you for the work you put into your posts. They are always informative and beautifully illustrated.
ReplyDeleteI do hope your household woes are now over. And I too delight in birds bathing.
Paris 'burned' last month. They say, it is the curse of colonialism. France, being a significant colonial power in her past is not, and won't be let to forget that, by those from the colonies who now live in France and have french citizenship. The north africans, for example. Parades or not, history neither forgets nor forgives.
ReplyDeleteI do hope your AC is fixed and will stay fixed. 97 degrees is very tough. I'm glad you put water out for the birds. Talking of too many national flags, I always assumed that Americans who put their flag over everything are extremists too. I have seen US flags behind Trumpist announcements, but maybe American moderates also love their flag, and it is not a far right symbol there. Interesting to know that it's a sign of extremism elsewhere in Europe except Britain. Yesterday I saw the British PM has just announced that he is granting 100 environmentally damaging oil drilling licenses in the North Sea. It will add to pollution, badly damage already threatened marine life and will only really benefit oil companies (in which his wealthy family has shares). He's presenting this move as him being on the side of motorists, even though the government#s own figures show it won't help motorists. To see this kind of dreadful stuff plastered over a big Union Jack makes me feel really sad and ashamed.
ReplyDeleteI learned so much in this extensive blog post, and I am so glad you are back and doing well it seems. And your pictures, both recent and historical are wonderful!
ReplyDeletehels - Thank you for your comment and for the list of books, I'll check them.
ReplyDeleteDUTA - you are absolutely right. France has a lot of problems in that direction, and I'll address them in another post. This post was mostly about India. Thanks for your comment.
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed reading your post, and I'm glad to see you back to your old tricks!! As usual you offer some fascinating and obscure but significant information, this time about the relationship of France and India.
ReplyDeleteI hope all your household repairs finally work out and you will have A/C where you need it soon.
best, mae at maefood.blogspot.com
Hi Vagabonde, Welcome back! Sorry to hear about the problems at both of your homes. I'm surprised that you haven't sold the Georgia house. Cost of maintenance alone would force me to do it... We have a tree just over the property line that is dying from the top down and our neighbor won't cut it down, and it is a concern to us as it would fall on our garage.
ReplyDeleteClimate change...hard to deny but plenty of people do. Even if the climate change was part of a natural cycle, it is here. Add in a few billion humans...and that has to exacerbate the problem.
It is depressing and sad to see the problems that France is having...too reminiscent of scenes in the USA (without the guns) I'm looking forward to your take on the issues.
I'm not sure about Modi...radical right? Love to be a dictator. I'm not sure but he reminds me of Erdogan in Turkey, just not as much in control...yet. Of course, our politics here are also quite a mess but its all relative.
I didn't know anything about Indian troops or European troops from other colonies during WWII and especially during WWI. (Except the Gurkhas)
As a stamp collector, I'm always interested in stamps from former colonies, enclaves, city states, etc. I have a number of stamps from French India. With only 6 enclaves and 200 square miles, it is more interesting than many others. I do like French Colonial Stamps...
I hope that your air conditioning is functioning and other repairs have been made. Take Care, Big Daddy Dave
I really enjoyed this, both for the history of the Bastille Day in more detail, coverage of the parade and then the information on the relationship with India. ("Madeleine" has long been a hero of mine; I've read a fair bit about her.)
ReplyDeleteI sure hope that by now you have the home things/AC resolved. So hard when it is so stifling hot. (More than once I've taken those cold beanbag packets I keep in the freezer or cooler ice wrapped up and hold it in bed for a bit. It does help you cool down when you don't have AC. (I don't and only would probably use it about five days of the year but we can get very hot and humid here!)
Glad to know you are doing OK now - household emergencies rear their ugly heads far too often - especially when houses get older like us, and trees grow too tall and can no long weather storms.
ReplyDeleteWonderful informative post as always, vintage photos marvelous - you are amazing!
Take care in the heat - NC is baked dry, the heat has been so bad this summer. Roll on autumn - won't be back in France where my brother lives, but will be home in England for a couple of weeks.
Hugs ~ Mary
So sorry about the trees on your Georgia house--and all the other problems. I'd long been aware of the Anglo-Indian troops but hadn't realized the extent of their involvement in France. And the story of Noor Khan is heartbreaking. Thank you for sharing this wealth of information and wonderful photos!
ReplyDeleteThanks for this super detailed page, I particularly enjoyed the vintage pictures of le défilé !
ReplyDeletePondichéry : "I was there" recently thanks to Antoine Laurain's latest book translated into English: An Astronomer in Love - on the French astronomer Le Gentil - excellent novel
https://wordsandpeace.com/2023/06/26/book-review-an-astronomer-in-love/
For a decade we owned a terrace house in Drefféac, a small village in Loire Atlantique. I learned a lot about France from the village's artisans. M. Nicolas, the menuisier, could be highly amusing but was frugal with words. "What happens on Le Quatorze?" I asked him. "Boules, then people dance." Politely I asked him to add to this - a few historical references, hein? - but he merely repeated the same sentence
ReplyDeleteHis wife spoke longer sentences and after I introduced them to Scotch from Scotland (as opposed to the indigenous supermarket rotgut) she welcomed me into her house and we had long conversations. She also provided a sort of sous-titre service to her husband, expanding some of his replies when conciseness got the better of understanding.
Their son had recently divorced and it seemed this preyed on her mind. But she refused to be be gloomy in my presence. She smiled, "Mais il a refait sa ve.", followed by the inevitable shrug. The simplicity of that has somehow always stayed with me.
I always learn a lot of new things for me, Vagabonde. For example, today I learned about the French colonies in India. I saw a photo of Indian troops at the July 14th parade. It's amazing how much trouble happened to your house in May-June. And now the tree has fallen. I hope that now all the troubles are over.
ReplyDeleteTake care!
You know your French and Indian history!
ReplyDeleteWe were in France on Bastille Day a few years ago, staying at a small town in the foothills of the Pyrenees, but we didn't see much celebratory activity. We hadn't even realized that it was the holiday until we went to buy groceries and the store was closed!
ReplyDeleteBonjour Vagabonde !
ReplyDeleteC'est la première fois de ma vie que je ne regarde pas le Défilé du 14 Juillet.
D'ailleurs, il y avait beaucoup moins de spectateurs que d'habitude.
Il est fort notre président, il arrive même à faire en sorte que les Français ne s'intéressent plus à cet évènement. D'ailleurs une grande majorité des Français ne s'intéresse plus à lui non plus. J'ai vu aux infos qu'il avait été hué, sifflé et on entendait "Macron démission".
Pour la cérémonie à l'Arc de Triomphe à Paris pour le 8 Mai, il n'a fait le déplacement que pour lui-même, la place a été barricadée empêchant toute approche du public.
J'espère que tu vas bien.
Je t'embrasse.
Thank you for a very interesting post.
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed reading your words and seeing the images you've shared.
I do hope all of your house problems/issues are sorted.
All the best Jan
Beautiful blog
ReplyDeleteLove this post. Thx for the Indian history lesson, Saskia!
ReplyDelete